Feb 5, 2014

Posted by | 6 Comments

5 Brilliant Responses to the Statement, “My Little Sister Could Do That!”

5Responses1

As art teachers, we are often challenged by our students when they are confronted by modern art. “My little sister could do that!” they exclaim. It’s up to us to defend the entire history of art. Here are five responses that are sure to work.

Response #1: Ask Students, “What is This Work of Art About?”

Art, as most people understand it is purely representational. There is a misconception that the better an artist can accurately recreate a recognizable image, the better the art. Likewise, if an artist is creating a portrait and it looks nothing like the person, the artist has failed. However, the world of modern art opens our eyes to the understanding that art can be so much more than recreation. Art can be about how paint is applied, about an element like line or color, about a principle like repetition or unity, or it could be against all that is art like Dadaism. Ask the student, “If the art isn’t representational, then what do you think this work is about?”

Response #2: Have Students Ponder, “Why Didn’t I Think of That?”

A few years ago everyone was going crazy over Silly Bandz, the rubber bands shaped like animals that could be worn as bracelets. It was the simplest of ideas yet everyone wanted one. How many people thought, “Why didn’t I think of that?” Sometimes artists are working towards breaking past how the public views art. They are looking for an idea that has not been explored, or at least not in a particular way. Like Silly Bandz, new ideas in art can be very simplistic in execution but complex in concept.

Response #3: Dive Into a Discussion of the Evolution of Art

Imagine for a moment that you are a robot and you are gathering information about the human species. Since you were built, you have no understanding that people start as babies and grow into adults. If at this point in your cybernetic life you were asked about people, you would respond, “I don’t get where people come from.” Without understanding the concept of growth, it would be impossible to explain. Understanding modern art is very similar. Artists look at what previous artists did before and build on their ideas. The Impressionist inspired the Post Impressionists, which in turn inspired Abstract Expressionism. Understanding the evolution of art helps us understand art.

Response #4: Liken it to a Math Problem

If you remember high school algebra, you can solve complex math problems. On the other hand, if you are like me, an algebraic equation looks like a jumbled series of numbers and letters. If I didn’t know better, I would say that a complex math equation is simply a string of nonsense.

To some, a work of modern art may look the way an algebraic equations looks to me, a string of letters and numbers that makes no sense. However, when one understands that the artist had a purpose and method behind the creation of the art, one comes to realize that it is not gibberish but the equivalent of the solution to a great math equation.

Response #5: Remind Students, “It Might Be Harder Than You Think.”

Pablo Picasso is quoted as saying, “It took me four years to paint like Raphael, but a lifetime to paint like a child.” Children paint with a certain innocence that is difficult to replicate. Advertisements often display art supposedly created by children. However, anyone who is familiar with children’s art can easily recognize that these works are created by adults pretending to paint like kids. Sometimes a work of modern art looks deceptively simplistic when, in reality, it may have taken a lifetime to learn to do.

So, what’s your answer to the statement, “My kid could do that!?”

Are there any artists you secretly feel that way about? Why? 

 

IanThis article was written by AOE Team member Ian Sands. Ian is the incredibly creative HS Art Teacher from Apex High in North Carolina. Ian is originally from NYC where he received a BFA from the School of Visual Arts.

About Ian | Ian’s Articles

Print Friendly

  • https://sites.google.com/site/spscarlisleartroom/ Krngriffith

    After a bit of discussion and thorough history we recreate it. Sometimes with especially my middle school “doing is seeing” is my speech. My favorite is Jackson Polllock which I plan during snow. I always get how easy it looks etc. so I show a video of him painting it and see how large some of his paintings are. Then I take my students outside with big containers of watered down paint and a brush and create our own with the snow as the canvas! I got the idea from another art teacher she does this on the snow plow mountains with her Kindergarten. Here is the blog I run for our art teachers of my students going at it. They do find respect for the artist doing this by himself.
    http://dioceseharrisburgartteacherstechspot.blogspot.com/2011/02/cool-snow-idea.html

    • iansands

      Wow, the paint in the snow images are fantastic!

  • Carol

    Very timely for me! I’m taking a large group to Boston MFA tomorrow and have memorized these truly brilliant responses!

  • Keeli

    I always always answer, “Maybe you COULD do that, but he thought of it first!”

    • http://www.theartofed.com/ Jessica Balsley

      I agree, Keeli. I like to talk about the IDEA to create in a new way being just as important as the finished piece itself.

  • Bonnie

    We take a vote when we first look at it to see who thinks it was easy to do and who thinks it was hard to do. I pick random students to defend/support thier vote. After a few answers we look at the art elements first and then move on to to the principles of art. We also discuss if there is a clear mood that would describe the artwork and why the artist may have made the work. Sometimes I can’t get the students to stop talking about the artwork once we start! In the end I tell the students some artwork may not be your favorite style but it still needs to be recognized as art.